Beta Testing with Google and Amazon
Google Needs to Catch Up to Amazon with Beta Testing
We at Voice2Biz use Amazon’s skill beta test program mechanism to beta test the skills we build for you.
Amazon has the customer in mind and makes it very easy to add and manage beta testers. Simply give Amazon the list of beta email addresses and Amazon takes care of the rest. You can use any email address that is associated with an Alexa device. Amazon sends the tester an invite email and makes it easy to join the testing. Simple and effective.
Actions on Google beta testing? Nada.
Google still has no clue in this area as to what it takes to bring an Action to market through a real product process (or refuses to care). They have “testing”, but they don’t have Actions *beta* testing; they have *alpha* testing for other developers.
In order to add others to help test your Google action, they MUST have a gmail account because Google effectively uses the Google development console as their way to test. There is no automated invite to your beta testers.
Once you add testers via read-only development permissions, you have to manually copy and email a link to them. The tester then has to follow the link, manually toggle the action’s Test Status to “Active” and then click “Start”. Again, all this happens in a convoluted (for the uninitiated) Google developer console.
To top things off, whenever you invoke an action in test, Google prefaces the invocation response with, “Okay, let me get the test version of xxxx”. It does this *every time* you invoke the test action. This causes interesting and considerable grief with our beta testers when they’re trying to run through dozens of invocations.
Google; get your act together.
Alexa can be the roach motel of skills; They go IN but don't come OUT Developers unable to remove their skills from the Alexa Store We had an instance where we needed to remove a skill from the Alexa store for a period of time. Normally, this is easy: just...read more
Choosing your smart speaker vendor Alexa or Google? Navigating hardware decisions We founded Voice2Biz Inc years ago on the premise that our technology and services would serve all smart speakers so whatever device you chose, we’d be there. Initially, that meant all...read more
Amazon Alexa has a client data security risk with Cross-Origin Resource Sharing (CORS)read more